To me it's so simple. Government shouldn't be running sports. Then it doesn't have to be government policy.
What happens if the supreme court recognizes claims to rights that both parties have? The most likely result is that they will weigh some rights against others. But they have an opporutinity to recognize that the government can't run sports without violating somebody's rights (hypotetically) and say that government then can't do it. Then sports will go to private organizations where it belongs. It's the most unlikely outcome. But it is the one I'm hoping for.
It seems to me the only right at stake here is women's right to exclude males from their sports. i.e., the right to create an organization that excludes males. You're right, the government (and courts) shouldn't force them to allow males in.
Log in
Article link
To me it's so simple. Government shouldn't be running sports. Then it doesn't have to be government policy.
What happens if the supreme court recognizes claims to rights that both parties have? The most likely result is that they will weigh some rights against others. But they have an opporutinity to recognize that the government can't run sports without violating somebody's rights (hypotetically) and say that government then can't do it. Then sports will go to private organizations where it belongs. It's the most unlikely outcome. But it is the one I'm hoping for.
It seems to me the only right at stake here is women's right to exclude males from their sports. i.e., the right to create an organization that excludes males. You're right, the government (and courts) shouldn't force them to allow males in.
Imho the obvious solution here is to create MtF and FtM categories in sports, let them compete among themselves.